A New Perspective on Medieval Leprosy

Medieval Leprosy, via Getty

Medieval Leprosy, via Getty

Leprosy was an epidemic disease that not only infected millions of people over a span of thousands of years, but it still remains a threat in Third World countries. Due to its destructive effects on the flesh of those infected, leprosy created a history of fear and segregation caused by misconceptions and rumor. In the United Kingdom, during the Middles Ages, 1050 to 1550 CE, leprosy reached its highest prevalence.  In the mid-twelfth century alone it is estimated that there were 1.5 million cases of leprosy in England and Scotland. From the 11th to 16th centuries in England there were over 300 documented leper hospitals, most of which were founded prior to the 14th century. While it was thought that these hospitals were a location for outcasted leper victims, it has been found that they served a wide range of individuals suffering from diverse diseases and health issues.

A new article by Roffey and Tucker (2013) examines the leper hospital of St Mary Magdalen in Winchester, UK. The site is located on the outskirts of the medieval town, a common location for these types of institutions. it was founded in the 11th century, and is first documented as a leper hospital in the mid-12th century. By the 14th century it had expanded its function and opened to other types of diseases and health concerns. A total of 54 burials were found at the site, with 49 complete inhumations and 5 scattered remains. The graves were anthropomorphic, meaning they were shaped like a general outline of the body with a large cutout for the main portion and smaller section for the skull. The study focuses on a smaller sample from the cemetery consisting of 38 individuals. These were separate from the others spatially, and date primarily from the 11th to mid-12 centuries. The other 11 complete inhumations were found within the church itself and were all older adults. They were likely patrons. The sample of 38 individuals from the external cemetery consists of 18 sub-adults and 20 adults. It is thought that these were the patients of the hospital.

Leprosy evidenced from destruction of facial bones, Roffey and Tucker 2013

Leprosy evidenced from destruction of facial bones, Roffey and Tucker 2013

Leprosy is a chronic infection of the peripheral nervous system, and in its secondary phase can cause changes to the bone. It is highly infectious, transmitted through infected droplets, and incubates over a long period of time. In skeletal remains, leprosy appears as distinctive changes in the facial bones including rounding and enlargement of the nasal aperture, destruction of the small nasal bones, and resorption (loss) of jaw bone. Remodeling and loss of bone most frequently occurs in the hands and feet. There can also be bony buildup on the limb bones in reaction to the infection. Loss of phalanges and limbs can also occur due to the loss of nerve sensation.

Of the individuals buried in the external cemetery, 84% had skeletal evidence for leprosy. In comparison with other known leper hospitals, this is an extremely high percentage. At St James and St Mary Magdalene in Chichester, 19.5% of individuals had skeletal indicators of leprosy. The site of St John Timberhill in Norwich had similar results, with 19.4% leprous individuals. There was also a much higher percentage of sub-adults with leprosy at the site under investigation in comparison with others. A potential reason for the discrepancies between sites may be that leprosy only affects bone in 3-5% of the cases. The hospital at St Mary Magdalen in Winchester may be a site where the worst cases were taken, whereas other locations accepted a full range of leprous individuals, many of which may have only shown soft tissue manifestations of the infection.

However, Roffey and Tucker (2013) argue that this site was unlike many other leper hospitals in England, and  was truly dedicated to leprosy. Often these hospitals would end up taking care of anyone with disfiguring diseases or other outcasts of society. However, St Mary Magdalen of Winchester may represent an actually dedicated leper hospital. Given its earlier date, this may be one of the first types of this institution, which in later variations expanded its purpose. Despite the fact that they were consigned to a life outside of the normal town, the evidence from the cemetery and site show that the lepers were not down-trodden outcasts, but rather were well-taken care of and provided proper burials.

The article concludes with one warning that I find extremely interesting. Roffey and Tucker (2013) warn against the interpretation that lepers were seen as sinners and that their disease was somehow thought to be related to religious downfall. They posit that this interpretation is more likely due to Victorian biomedical and segregationist ideas than based on actual medieval experience. As archaeological work reveals more evidence for leprosy in this period, it appears that these hospitals were not homes to the stigmatized outcasts, but rather were charitable institutions and refuges.

Works Cited

ResearchBlogging.orgRoffey, S., & Tucker, K. (2012). A contextual study of the medieval hospital and cemetery of St Mary Magdalen, Winchester, England International Journal of Paleopathology, 2 (4), 170-180 DOI: 10.1016/j.ijpp.2012.09.018

8 responses to “A New Perspective on Medieval Leprosy

  1. There is a place in Carlow, Ireland called Ballynalour in Irish Baile na Lobhair which means town/ townland of the lepers. There is a leper hospital marked in the area. Loads of townland and place names in Ireland refer to lepers and many of these were the sites of leper hospitals. There’s also skeletal evidence from excavations in Dublin showing that many lived to have very advanced cases of leprosy indicating a high level of care for the victims. There are a number of places in Ireland which refer to one leper also, rather than referring to the plural suggesting that they owned the land themselves (Joyce 1910)

  2. Pingback: Waltham Abbey – the rise and fall of a medieval church « The Templar Knight·

  3. Pingback: A New Perspective on Medieval Leprosy | The Knights Templar revisited·

  4. Hi Katy,This post is interesting to me as I live in Crete where the Island of Spinalonga was once a leper colony. The first time I visited I was so overhelmed by the story of their sufferings at that time. I became involved with the Leprosy Mission helping to raise funds.I meet with other missions from England who come here to Spinalonga. Also, the author Victoria Hislop wrote a book called “The Island ” fiction based on fact from which a T.V. series was made where I was cast as one of the lepers. It was a special experience one that I will never forget.

  5. Pingback: Not Dead Yet: Medieval Versus Modern Leprosy | Bones Don't Lie·

  6. Pingback: Best Mortuary Archaeology Finds of 2013 | Bones Don't Lie·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s